The First Piano Concerto, like its successor, is in three movements, the first of which rocks and sways with dissonance. By contrast the second ('Slow Blues') is candidly bluesy - a questing dream in aquamarine. It tends towards the woozily disorientating. The finale sends sparks and shudders in all directions but at its centre there is some very inward-speaking music. It's all recorded with attractive directness in a superb hall.
Francis Shaw has every reason to thank Martin Jones, the orchestra and the conductor. I cannot imagine this music being presented with greater skill or more persuasively. Even so this, for me, is not the most commanding entry in Lyrita's illustrious and compellingly attractive catalogue. It's all most attentively played and superbly recorded. Lyrita admirers, understandably legion, will want this. Francis Shaw will have his enthusiasts - and I would like to hear more. Rob Barnett, Musicweb-international
The revised concerto is as pithy as it is purposeful, employing an uncompromising but by no means intimidating language, and whose outer movements frame a heartfelt 'Slow Blues'. Here the piano writing unfolds as if a refraction of subdued Erroll Garner or Art Tatum improvisation, while the slow trumpet surely acknowledges the haunting slow movement of the Gershwin concerto. As for the actual performances, Martin Jones emerges as an exemplary champion, and the composer draws a spirited response from his hard working Bratislava band. The recorded sound is big and bold to match. Inquisitive collectors can safely investigate. Andrew Achenbach, The Gramophone
Robert Matthew-Walker’s very helpful notes typify the music as ‘a late twentieth-century expansion of serial thematicism’ but the broad base of tonality and the sense of forward movement, also mentioned, were more than enough to win me over. Overall there’s little here that lovers of Copland and Bartók would not respond to well.
I need hardly add that Martin Jones, though even older than me, proves himself supremely equal to anything that the composer demands of him. As Dominy Clements wrote of the Nimbus 4-CD 75th Birthday Tribute - anything to which he turns his hand is a true delight.
With the composer himself on the podium, of course, the performances can be regarded as authoritative, which is just as well since I have no benchmark with which to compare them. This is, indeed, the only Francis Shaw recording in the UK catalogue.
The recording is in Lyrita’s best manner. Perhaps now they will bring us more of Francis Shaw’s prolific output, or maybe another advocate of British music will oblige: Chandos, Hyperion, Dutton or Naxos? Meanwhile I hope that Lyrita’s enterprise in recording this greatly undervalued composer receives strong support. Brian Wilon, MusicWeb-International